This is my Lord of the Rings page. Nothing fancy :)
Here is how I fixed the Gollum up-kicker missing:
The post cap rubber fits right over the tooth of the habitrail. I tried installing two to make it symmetrical, but this caused it to miss alot. I picked the rear one next, and it has been working almost perfectly now.
I should mention I tried many other things, and this was the only thing that worked for me!
I got the pst cap rubber from Terry at Pinballlife.
http://www.pinballlife.com/page110.html
Have fun!